About CommentOnThis.comThis is a site designed to make it easier to take the core of large published reports and allow anyone to comment on them. More... |
Contents:
Britain in the World
Partnership in Power - Draft Final Year Documents
DRAFT - This is a discussion paper only.
The content of this document does not necessarily reflect
Government or Labour Party policy.
Comment: Cities of London and Westminster CLP
We believe Labour's role in modern society is to work through government, civic society and local communities for a more equal distribution of income, power, ... Reply?. Introduction
Labour's international policy is driven by Britain's national interest and Labour's core values
of social justice, equality and opportunity for all. In the last eleven years Britain's role and
influence has strengthened and we have witnessed unprecedented progress around the
world with greater access to healthcare, education and a safer environment for many.
Labour has been at the forefront of this fight for global equality. However in order to ensure
progress continues to be made we must be vigilant to the new challenges we face including
extremism and international terrorism, weapons proliferation, and failed states and regional
instability.
As the structure and nature of the world changes our international policy must also evolve
to reflect new trends and deal with new challenges. It is only through creating a global
society and working with a wide range of groups- both governmental and nongovernmental-
that we can address these challenges. Globalisation represents great
opportunity but in order to ensure it benefits everyone individual potential must be
unlocked through collective action at all levels of society.
Working to ensure a fairer world for all remains central to Labour's core values. We will
continue to lead the battle against world poverty and play an active role in the world to
ensure that where you are born does not determine your chances in life. We will also
continue to stand firm against threats to national security and to peace, freedom and
democracy around the world and continue the fight against human rights abuses which has
always been central to our foreign policy.
Achieving these goals requires strong bilateral relationships with our international partners.
A Labour Government will work to create strong and effective international rules and
institutions. In the long term it is only through effective international institutions that we
can safeguard our national security. This is why our position on the UN Security Council
should be used to the full, not least to accelerate the pace of reform at the UN. That is also
why the Labour Government has been right to press for full engagement in the European
Union so it turns outwards to lead in tackling the main global challenges.
Eleven years ago we were isolated in Europe now we are leading the debate on issues
including international development, climate change and how to secure continued economic
prosperity. We will demonstrate to British citizens the benefits that EU membership has
brought to Britain and show what we can achieve when we work together on issues of
huge international importance.
The Conservatives have said we should be 'sceptical' about global engagement. They are
wrong. We should be committed to it. Britain has strong links around the globe and, just as
the City has become a global hub for finance, Britain should see itself as a global hub. That
requires a foreign policy led by clear priorities. Unlike the Conservative Party's introspective
and isolationist approach to foreign policy we will remain outward looking and
internationalist by building and maintaining alliances around the world.
Tackling World Poverty
The last eleven years have seen a revolution in the fight against global poverty and Labour
is proud to have been one of its leaders. The Department for International Development,
established by Labour in 1997, is recognised as a model for overseas development around
the world and demonstrates Labour's commitment in this area. We are on track to meet our
commitment to the UN target of 0.7 per cent of Gross National Income (GNI) in aid spending
by 2013, two years ahead of the UN goal.
Comment: Add, page 3, line 9, at end of line:
“We shall then increase our commitment to 1% of Gross National Income.”
Supporting Argument: This would increase aid above the UN target of 0.7% Reply?.
Comment: Cities of London and Westminster CLP
add: “We shall then increase our commitment to 1% of Gross National Income.” Reply?.
However, much more still needs to be done to tackle world poverty. While the number of
people living on less than $1 a day has decreased this is largely due to growth in Asia; it has
actually increased in Sub-Saharan Africa. We will ensure that between 2004 and 2010, total
UK bilateral and multilateral aid to Africa will double, as pledged at Gleneagles. We cannot
afford to be complacent and will develop innovative and effective responses to
international poverty whilst encouraging others to do the same.
Delivering on our promises
"World Vision welcomes the Labour Party's commitment to fulfilling the UK's pledge
to increase the UK aid budget to 0.7% of GNI by 2013 and would urge continued
efforts to work closely with European and other international partners to ensure
that they also meet their commitments and that the MDGs are achieved." World Vision
At the Millennium Summit in 2000 the international community - every world leader,
every international body, and almost every country - vowed to spare no effort to achieve
the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) to;
Leaders at the Gleneagles G8 Summit in July 2005 agreed a momentous plan to fight
poverty and to ensure the MDGS are reached by 2015 but today the international
community is off-track in meeting these goals and it is clear that we are facing a
development emergency. Whilst the UK is on target to meet our commitments we need
fresh momentum to ensure that European and other international partners do the same.
We are leading an international campaign that brings together governments, civil society,
trade unions, the private sector, cities and faith groups to get the world back on track in
achieving the MDGs. This culminates in a UN Secretary General led event in September 2008
where the international community can redouble its efforts to meet the MDGs.
It is not only the quantity of aid that matters but the way it is delivered. Labour will ensure
effective aid delivery with policies across government aligned to tackle poverty and we will
target our aid on those areas and people who need it most. We will continue supporting
innovative methods of development assistance including the International Finance Facility
and will double our funding for science and technology research in order to find new drugs
and new technologies to assist with agricultural development and management of climate
change.
As collectively the world's largest aid donor, a significant humanitarian aid supplier and the
world's largest trading bloc, the European Union matters for development. Labour has been
at its heart calling for greater aid effectiveness and transparency. There have been
substantial improvements in European aid effectiveness since reform - which the Labour
Government called for - began in 2000, but more needs to be done. We supported the
Lisbon Treaty which is a long awaited opportunity to improve the coherence in European aid
structures and further help drive aid effectiveness. We continue to work to ensure that the
European Union delivers on its promises to help people around the world
The role of trade
No country in the developing world has reduced poverty in the last 30 years without
increasing growth. In 2005 world leaders pledged to make it easier for poor countries to
export their products yet progress on the Doha trade round has been slow. We have made
pressing for a trade deal at Doha that helps lift millions out of poverty a priority. Poor
countries need time to manage the transition to more open markets and should not be
forced to liberalise at the expense of their development. That is why we have fought for
flexibility in the EU Economic Partnership Agreements. We strongly support trade policies
and agreements being based on research and analysis of their likely social, economic and
environmental impacts, and encourage this wherever possible.
In recognition of the strong links between capacity building and economic development we
will contribute to a multi-million pound 'aid for trade' programme for poor countries to help
build the necessary infrastructure to take advantage of trading opportunities.
Government action is crucial but is not sufficient on its own. It is only through increasing
public awareness about fair trade and working with retailers to encourage fairer and more
transparent business practices that we can really help to improve the lives of millions of
people worldwide
Promoting good governance
"Britain should encourage the building of democracy and free education provision
throughout the world as a long term goal, in order to foster political change and
45 improvement on a wider basis." City of Durham CLP open policy forum
The march of political democracy in the past 20 years - 56 more countries have established
democratic systems - is striking. But the speed of progress has not been matched by similar
development of sub-national government and social and civic institutions. The checks and
balances of democratic governance are important for the security and development of any
society: from established systems like ours to the new democracies of Eastern Europe and
Africa to the emerging economies of China and the Middle East.
Poor governance hinders economic and social development, and creates opportunities for
extremism, terrorism, and transnational crime. Working for good governance around the
world will remain at the heart of our foreign and development policy. We will deliver a global
partnership for development that stretches beyond governments and politicians, to engage
citizens, civil society, business and trade unions to ensure that governments work
effectively.
The UK's new Governance and Transparency Fund is an invaluable resource which will
enable local groups to better hold their governments to account. Its funds have already
increased from £100 million to £130 million in recognition of the interest it has generated.
The bottom-up approach embodied in this initiative highlights the grass-roots approach we
will continue to take to development through encouraging local involvement wherever
possible rather than imposing top down solutions which may not be best suited to
development needs.
Good governance is important at all levels. The provision of effective public services can
only be achieved where central and local government work in harmony. We will continue to
promote this and support the role that peer review mechanisms and regional bodies can play
in promoting good governance
Tackling corruption is essential to improving good governance and ensuring effective aid
delivery. We will ensure that the delivery of UK aid takes into account governance
arrangements, corruption and adherence to human rights. Strengthening public services and
civil society in developing countries can help to reduce levels of corruption but we must also
tackle the money-laundering channels which allow corruption to flourish.
We have already signed and ratified the UN convention against corruption and are the
largest donor to the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) which was set up to
fight corruption through increased transparency of payments from companies to
governments and to help make sure that natural resources and the wealth they generate
are well governed. We will continue to provide practical support to governments to help
them investigate corruption and will continue to publish an annual UK action plan to tackle
corruption affecting developing countries. We will work to reduce bribery and moneylaundering
by UK companies and will continue to build on the strength of the dedicated
overseas corruption unit, established by Labour in 2006, to investigate allegations of
bribery and money laundering.
Enhancing security and meeting fundamental human needs
"Security is best achieved by working towards elimination of world poverty" Exeter CLP
In the UK, access to public services and social security is a fundamental right and we will
work with developing countries to ensure this is a right world-wide. We will commit half of
our direct bilateral support to public services meeting fundamental human needs such as
healthcare, education, sanitation and fighting disease, and will work with developing
countries to help deliver National Action Plans. We will also support essential private sector
investment and job creation, including through reforms to international trade rules, giving
support to the quality as well as the quantity of investment.
Providing effective public services is impossible without addressing the insecurity, conflict
and failed states that cost lives, put human rights at risk and prevent progress in
development. There are a number of faltering states in the post-cold war world. We can see
the challenges of governance in countries where the state is weak - Afghanistan, Iraq and
Somalia. We also see examples in Burma and Zimbabwe of where the state is too strong,
undemocratic and unaccountable and failing to respect human rights or respond to human
needs. It is in all our interests to address the poor governance that can lead to conflict and
instability. We will continue to work with international allies to prevent the emergence of
failed states.
Fighting disease
"We welcome the International Health Partnership launched by the Prime Minister
last September, and the focus on developing health systems in the global south"
UNISON Labour Link
Fighting disease is vital for achieving the Millennium Development Goals. Although there has
been progress with life expectancy in the developing world increasing by a quarter in the
last forty years, we need to work harder to tackle disease especially with new strains of
disease and the risks that climate change poses to health.
Disease is not purely a health issue but an economic, social and political problem. Every year
2.5 million people are infected with the HIV virus. We will tackle both the treatment and
prevention of HIV and AIDS through, among other measures, greater education, investment
in drugs and support for carers. We will also maintain efforts to achieve the global goal of
universal access to prevention and treatment and care programmes by 2010.
Too many people in the developing world die of preventable diseases such as polio and
tuberculosis. In order to tackle these diseases we will ensure greater access to vaccinations
by working with pharmaceutical companies to encourage low pricing initiatives. Too many
people die every day simply because they don't have clean water to drink or live in
unsanitary conditions. Providing clean water and sanitation is crucial for reducing disease.
We have already doubled our assistance to water and sanitation in Africa to £95 million a
year and will more than double this to £200 million a year by 2010/11. We will ensure that
this aid is targeted at those countries which are furthest away from meeting the MDG on
water and sanitation. In Southern Afghanistan, our Armed Forces are working with local
forces to improve security. They are also working with aid officials and local government to
build hundreds of new wells.
Every year, malaria causes more than one million estimated deaths, mostly in Sub-Saharan
Africa. Britain has been in the vanguard of the fight against malaria. We have supported the
targeting of malaria through the use of insecticide- treated mosquito nets. We will
contribute £100 million to fund 20 million more bed nets- one of the most effective ways
of preventing malaria over extended periods.
The Labour Government's launch of a new International Health Partnership between donor
countries, developing countries and other health agencies was an important step in tackling
the problems of coordination that can hinder health delivery and demonstrates our
commitment in this area. We will implement the International Finance Facility for
Immunisation, which aims to save five million lives over the next decade. We are currently
the world' second largest donor to the global fight against HIV and AIDS and will continue to
be a key donor to the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, TB and Malaria.
Many developing countries, particularly in Africa, suffer from a shortage of health workers
with poor pay and working conditions driving trained staff away. The Labour Government
will continue working with African governments to help build effective health systems and
create incentives, including better pay and job opportunities, to encourage health workers
to stay in their own countries.
Comment: Needs something about not enticing health workers to come and work in the NHS. Not easy to accomplish. perhaps something about enabling people to work here for a spell and then go back? Reply?.
Vulnerable groups
Poverty affects certain groups particularly badly. As well as women these include children,
disabled people and older people. We will ensure that development policy takes into
account the specific needs of these groups.
Labour is committed to education for all. In 2006 we announced £8.5 billion to help ensure
that, by 2015, children everywhere, boys and girls alike, will be able to complete at least five
years of quality education. In government we have supported the Lisbon Treaty which
enshrines children's rights for the first time in EU policy-making. We will extend the fight
against child poverty globally and will encourage universal access to education by helping
developing countries to eradicate school fees and increase awareness about the importance
of education. We will also continue working closely with the governments of poor countries
to improve both the access to and the quality of schooling.
Children suffer disproportionately from the effects of conflict whether through forced
conscription as child soldiers or because of disruptive effects to their education and
livelihoods. It is because Labour is committed to the rights of every child that we will seek to
provide education not just in places of comfort and peace but everywhere in the world by
ensuring that investment in conflict zones is targeted to support education. One of NATO's
greatest achievements in Afghanistan is to support the Afghan government in seeing many
millions more children, including girls, attending school compared to the situation before
2001.
Our work to improve developing countries' health systems, to increase access to basic
health services and to improve some of the other factors that affect health, such as water,
sanitation and female education will also help to reduce child mortality. We will also continue
to contribute to initiatives including the Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunisation and
Roll back Malaria which have helped revitalise interest in childhood diseases and
substantially increased the resources directed to child health.
We coordinated the signing of the UN Convention on Disability Rights. The Convention
covers areas such as the right to life, access to justice, personal mobility, health, education
and work.
Women in the World
Women represent the future of their countries and their empowerment must be one of our
most important foreign policy goals. Women suffer disproportionately from the effects of
poverty and under-development - around 70 per cent of the 1.3 billion people who live in
extreme poverty are women and girls- yet many countries still do not recognise the huge
gender disparities that exist. Labour believes that addressing gender equality is not only a
moral necessity but is crucial to fighting global poverty and must be recognised in all
development policy. However it is important not to see women as victims, as they have
been hugely influential in achieving change and should be fully involved in decision-making
processes.
Economic and political empowerment
Increasing economic and political opportunities for women is fundamental to improving
women's lives and tackling poverty, extremism, and conflict. In many parts of the developing
world women dominate the informal economy and greater support needs to be given to
them. It is estimated that 8 out of 10 microfinance clients are women and we will continue
our support for microfinance initiatives. We have already pledged £35 million over the next
two years to the Government of Afghanistan's microfinance scheme. These loans are giving
women the chance to start or expand small businesses, engage in the economy, and gain a
degree of financial independence that would otherwise be out of reach.
Despite some limited progress women remain severely underrepresented in politics. But as
the case of Rwanda shows, where women now occupy almost half of the seats in the
National assembly, change is possible. Afghanistan now has significant numbers of women
in national and local politics, something which was illegal under the Taleban. We have
already worked with civil society and national governments in Sierra Leone to help increase
the number of women participating in parliamentary and local elections and we will continue
to work to help increase the representation of women in all sectors- both at home and
abroad.
Health
Every minute a woman dies in pregnancy or childbirth, yet many of these deaths are
preventable. In order to tackle this high level of maternal mortality we will ensure that
health provision helps meet women's needs. We have pledged to provide an additional £100
million by 2012 to the United Nations Population Fund to support governments in Africa
and South Asia to provide more condoms, contraceptive pills, and advice on better sexual
health to poor women, girls and men.
HIV and AIDS also have a huge impact on women. In Sub-Saharan Africa 61 per cent of 15-
24 year olds living with HIV and Aids are female. Whilst women are disproportionately
victims of AIDS they are also the principal providers of care and support. We will fund
gender-specific approaches to HIV and AIDS which address the barriers women face in
accessing treatment and contraception.
Violence against women
"Refuge supports the Millennium Development Goals, one of which includes
promoting gender equality and empowering women. Domestic violence is a human
rights issue and is closely linked to this goal yet for many women and children the
right to a life free of violence is consistently breached." Refuge
Many women continue to be the victims of violence, both within and outside the home. This
violence is often facilitated by a culture of silence and impunity and we will support work
with both men and women to increase education and tackle the gender norms which often
allow this violence to continue.
Gender-specific violence including rape, trafficking and prostitution is increasingly used as a
weapon during armed conflicts. The Labour Government has already provided £3.2 million to
the United Nations to encourage women's involvement in peace keeping and to help
prevent sexual violence in conflict and post conflict situations. We will work to ensure that
the vital role women can play in conflict reconstruction and peace agreements is
acknowledged by the international community.
UN Security Resolution 1325 on Women Peace and Security should guide our actions in
conflict and post-conflict zones and we will ensure its rigorous implementation.
A Global Society
Since the fall of the Berlin Wall the world has changed radically. At a time when power is
more dispersed than ever, with the rise of Asia, the global reach of companies and more
demanding citizens, Britain's influence will come through its relationships and networks.
Britain's leading position on the world stage means we have a moral responsibility to ensure
that the benefits of globalisation reach everyone in all corners of the world. There is not
only a moral argument to act but also a pragmatic one as national interest and shared
interest are often the same, with instability and poverty in one part of the world affecting
citizens worldwide.
Reforming global governance
"The UN Security Council should be reformed to reflect current realities, for example
through the inclusion of India and Brazil." Stirling CLP
Many of the new challenges we face today are not confined to national borders but demand
a global response. We will work to reform the international institutions of global governance
to meet the new challenges we face and to make them more inclusive, legitimate and
effective.
We are committed to an expanded United Nations Security Council to include influential
countries such as India, Brazil, Germany, Japan and an African nation. Reform of the UN must
reach across the whole organisation. We will support the 'One UN' approach which ensures
better coordination of UN departments through one in-country office and one budget. This
will ensure better aid delivery, increased humanitarian capacity and a more cohesive
approach to peace-keeping and peace-making. We will also build consensus among others to
speed up the pace of reform. We are also committed to ensuring that respect for human
rights, together with security and development are at its heart.
It is not only the UN that is in need of reform. We will also press international institutions
including international financial institutions to be more effective in responding to
development priorities. We will also work to ensure that the World Bank's development
programmes provide an integrated approach for tackling both poverty reduction and climate
change.
The UK Government has pioneered a 'country led' approach to development, avoiding
prescriptive economic conditionality, such as forced market liberalisation, on developing
countries. We will urge other countries and institutions to adopt a similar approach in
recognising the diverse needs of developing countries. We will also encourage them to untie
aid, as the UK government has done, so that developing countries are not required to
purchase certain goods and services in return for aid.
It is also vital that we help develop the capacity and strength of regional institutions as
these organisations are often best placed and possess the necessary local knowledge and
expertise to assist with conflict prevention, development and promoting human rights.
Other organisations including the Commonwealth and the G8 also play an important role in
the world. The Commonwealth represents nearly 30 per cent of the world's population but
is often undervalued as a source of power. We will also work to expand the G8 to reflect
shifts in the global balance of power enabling it to better address challenges such as climate
change. We will continue to play our full role in an enlarged and more outward-looking EU,
and support an enlarged and reformed NATO.
Working beyond government
Just as the structure of the international system has changed so have the actors within it.
We no longer live in a world where government action alone is enough. That is why we will
work with others to achieve global progress on international development.
As the 2005 Make Poverty History campaign demonstrated, the revolution in media and
communications enables new forms of global collective action, with government and global
non-governmental organisations able to support bottom-up pressure, both at home and
abroad These organisations also have a direct role to play on the ground, delivering
humanitarian aid and monitoring human rights abuses. It is only by working constructively
with such organisations that we can deliver on development.
We will also continue to work with organisations including the BBC World Service and the
British Council to influence opinion around the world.
In an increasingly interdependent world, trade unions have an important role to play in
helping to uphold core labour standards and campaigning on issues of social justice and
human rights. Trade unions are a vital component of civil society in both established and
emerging democracies and we will work to support them around the world.
Faith groups also play an important role in building public support at home and abroad and
providing crucial services to the poor. We will continue to engage with faith groups to tackle
global poverty, to promote inter-faith dialogue and to encourage progressive voices to
combat the religious extremism that often lies at the heart of international insecurity.
The reach of business is greater than ever and the private sector has an important role to
play in encouraging growth and ensuring fair business practice in the developing world. We
will work with the private sector to encourage their productive engagement on
development issues and ensure that their involvement is not harmful to the interests of the
developing world through encouraging greater corporate social responsibility. We will do this
by continuing to strengthen the Ethical Trading Initiative, which brings together retail
companies, NGOs and trade unions and strengthening innovative public-private sector
partnerships including the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, as well as other
corporate accountability initiatives at the global level.
Comment: When working witha the private sector to encourage their productive engagement on development issues they should also 'ensure that a system of minimum wage deals be enforced' - this is from Weston-super-Mare ... Reply?.
Global economy
Whilst globalisation can pose many new risks, an open global economy has driven economic
growth and raised living standards for people around the world. Continued economic
success internationally is vital for the UK's economy and society and crucial for development
across the world, in particular for success in emerging from conflict and state failure. That is
why we will to continue to press for open, effective and fair markets.
Comment: Whilst pressing for open, effective and fair markets these actions should be underlined by 'ensuring that child labour is abolished throughout the world'. From Weston-super-Mare CLP Reply?.
It is only by unlocking people's full potential that they can benefit fully from new global
opportunities. We will deliver an economic and social policy which ensures globalisation
benefits the many and not the few through encouraging free trade, open markets and
investment in people. Long term economic prosperity around the world cannot be achieved
without social justice. We will help developing countries to build civil society, implement core
labour standards, and promote sustainable development and public service investment.
The Prosperity and Work document covers issues concerning the domestic and international
economy.
The rise of Asia
"The Government must keep up the push around the largest emerging nations for
ethical development and human rights within world economic development."
Bexleyheath and Crayford CLP
Globalisation has changed the flows of people, trade and ideas across borders and has
affected the distribution of power. Nowhere is this more apparent than in Asia where the
growth of India and China represents the biggest shift of economic power in recent history.
We will acknowledge this change in our international strategy by maximising the economic
benefits that our relationship with these countries can provide. We will also continue to
engage in constructive dialogue with China on issues of concern, including human rights and
strengthening democracy. International institutions should also be reformed to reflect this
new balance of power.
Climate change and energy security
For many in the developing world climate change is not a future threat but a lived reality. It
is in the developing world that the negative impacts of climate change will be seen most
clearly and felt most quickly. Climate change is not only an environmental problem but also
an economic, social and political issue. Water shortages, flooding and reduced energy
supplies will have negative impacts on the economy and food production and potentially
exacerbate regional tensions and conflict. Climate change will also affect migratory patterns
with restricted resources or environmental change displacing many people. We must act
urgently to mitigate these problems.
As the green measures introduced in the 2008 Budget show Labour is committed to
tackling climate change. However domestic action is not enough and we will continue to
press for global, concerted efforts on this issue. It is particularly important to help
developing countries adapt to cope with the consequences of climate change and we will
push for greater international support for adaptation to climate change in the least
developed countries, and for clean energy investment in the developing world as a whole.
Over the next five years we will spend over £100 million on research into the science, social,
economic and security impact of climate change for the most vulnerable developing
countries.
We will continue to provide resources to deal with humanitarian disasters, likely to be more
prevalent with climate change. However, forward prevention must remain Labour's top
priority. As the recent Bali talks demonstrate it is only by speaking alongside our EU partners
that we can influence the international climate agenda and establish a post-Kyoto
framework by 2012.
We have also committed £800 million to an Environment Transformation Fund supporting
developing countries to tackle climate change through low-carbon energy investment,
adaptation and deforestation. In order to meet international commitments, we will work to
strengthen existing measures such as the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) and to
develop new and innovative policies and targets for instance on renewable energy and
biofuels.
We will develop a robust and diverse energy policy to ensure that we are not dependent on
imports from some of the world's most unstable regions We will also continue to develop
sustainable energy sources to reduce our external energy dependency.
Issues concerning climate change and energy security are covered in the Sustainable
Communities document
Securing Peace, Freedom and Democracy
We live in an age of unprecedented progress with more people living in peace than ever
before. However this progress is under threat from challenges including international
terrorism, extremism and failed states. This is why we will ensure that our foreign policy is
committed to defending the security of the British people and co-operating with
international institutions, to secure peace, freedom, democracy, economic security and
environmental protection for all.
We can only make the world a safer place through working with others and that is why our
international alliances are so important. A positive relationship with the US, as the world's
only superpower, is essential for the future and for ensuring progress on global challenges.
Strong relationships with our EU partners, with NATO and with emerging powers such as
Russia, India, Brazil and China are also vital.
The terrorist threat and tackling extremism
Since 11 September 2001 the world has changed dramatically. We will ensure that Britain
continues to adapt to new global security challenges. The Labour Government has launched
its National Security Strategy which outlines how we can protect the safety of our citizens
and fight global terrorism. We have increased spending across government on counterterrorism
from £1 billion in 2001 to £2 billion today with further increases planned to £3.5
billion in 2011, and the National Security Strategy will ensure that this increased
investment is better coordinated and targeted.
We will continue to strengthen our protection against terrorist attack, and our ability to
intercept and stop terrorist attacks and networks. We will continue to press for stronger
international alliances against terrorism, including disrupting the flow of terrorist finance
and violent extremist ideology. We will also help build stability and the rule of law in areas of
the world that would otherwise shelter terrorism.
Comment: Whilst helping to build stability and the rule of law in areas of the World that would otherwise shelter terrorism 'particular attention should be directed at the perceived causes of radicalism with a ... Reply?.
Building democratic and inclusive political systems around the world is vital for fighting
global terrorism which is why we will continue to support projects around the world to
strengthen civil society and national institutions. In Iraq and Pakistan we are working to
support the establishment of an independent judiciary. And in the Middle East, Central Asia
and Afghanistan we are working to promote an independent media through our support for
the BBC World Service's new BBC Arabic channel.
Global terrorism can only be fought by using a range of resources from military and economic
to cultural. We will continue to use the power of ideas and shared values to isolate extremism
and win the battle of hearts and minds, but recognise that in extreme cases the hard power
of military force is necessary in the fight against terrorism. Confronting the terrorist threat
is only possible through cooperation with international partners which is why we will fight
for strengthened international institutions, capable of deploying both hard and soft power.
The Crime, Justice, Citizenship and Equalities consultation document covers issues
concerning the domestic response to terrorism
The Middle East
"Unite supports a two-state solution and wants to see a peaceful solution for the
sake of all the people in the region." Unite
Achieving peace and stability in the Middle East is central to tackling many of the global
security threats that we face and resolving the situation in Israel and Palestine remains the
most important element. Since 1967 a two-state solution, a viable Palestine alongside a
secure Israel, has been the only way to establish both justice for the Palestinians and
security for Israel.
Comment: Add, page 16 at end of line 11:
“We welcome the work of former President Jimmy Carter to bring Hamas into the peace process on this basis, which we believe is necessary in order to end the human tragedy ... Reply?.
The 2007 Annapolis peace conference and the subsequent revival of final status
negotiations has helped advance dialogue and build momentum to finding a two-state
solution. The commitment to finding a solution thorough the Quartet (US, UN, EU, and
Russia) Roadmap is a positive step forward and we will continue to work towards lasting
peace in the Middle East.
We will also lead efforts to achieve economic development in the Middle East through our
pledge of £243 million in aid, linked to political progress between 2008 and 2011. We will
also support progress through development initiatives, supporting democratic institutions
and building civil society. It is clear that the need for vision and leadership by all parties has
never been greater.
Comment: Whilst supporting progress through development initiatives 'we will pursue a world-wide agreement to prevent the growth of drug production by encouraging the growth and the purchasing of sustainable edible ... Reply?.
Iraq and Afghanistan
British troops are currently on operations in Iraq and Afghanistan, putting their lives at risk
to support democratically elected governments. The Labour party is immensely grateful to
these men and women.
Comment: The governmnent of Iraq is barely democratically elected. As always in the Middle East, we interfere in the democratic process because we will not tolerate Arab democracies in case the outcome is not to ... Reply?.
In Iraq we are well down the path of handing over responsibility to its own security forces
under the control of its democratically elected government. We continue to have a role in
training and mentoring the security forces, and in maintaining 'overwatch', and we will
continue to assess the situation and the British contribution and requirement for troops in
Iraq based on military advice. It is crucial that progress in security and governance are
matched with economic regeneration and political progress, and we are working hard in both
these areas. Since 2003 we have committed £147 million in humanitarian assistance for
Iraq as a crucial part of post-conflict reconstruction, and we continue to support the political
process, including national reconciliation, and the economic regeneration of Basra. We will
continue to meet our obligations to the Iraqi government and people and provide the
necessary military, diplomatic and development resources to help them build peace and
stability.
Comment: Add, page 16 at end of line 11:
“We welcome the work of former President Jimmy Carter to bring Hamas into the peace process on this basis, which we believe is necessary in order to end the human tragedy ... Reply?.
In Afghanistan we will continue to meet our international obligations to the UN and to the
democratically elected Afghan Government and people, playing a leading role in a
multinational mission, with strong local support, to stabilise the country through improved
security, political unity, and economic development. In December 2007 we announced an
updated, long-term plan for security, political, social and economic development. This plan
emphasised greater integration between the military and civilian effort, closer partnership
with the Afghan Government and security forces, and more equitable burden-sharing across
the international community. Between 2009 and 2012 we will provide £450 million in
development and stabilisation assistance.
Comment: Delete from Page 16, line 30, from “In Afghanistan … international community” page 17, line 3 and Add:
“We recognise that the continued presence of British troops is counter-productive, contributing ... Reply?.
Comment: Latin America
Add, Page 17, line 5, new section headed “Latin America”:
“We welcome the recent elections of governments in Latin America, such as those in Venezuela, Argentina, Brazil and ... Reply?.
Supporting human rights
"Human Rights are not only a set of standards, which should not be violated, they
provide the international community with a set of tools to prevent abuses from
occurring and can empower people to achieve progressive change."
Amnesty International
Labour is committed to promoting human rights abroad, recognising that human rights
should provide the basic rules for a world in which we can all live in peace and dignity. Over
the last decade, concern for human rights has moved from the margins to the mainstream.
Internationally the establishment of the International Criminal Court and the arrest of highprofile
human rights abusers including Slobodan Milosevic were major steps forward for
international justice. This shift in attitudes highlights that human rights can no longer be
treated as a discrete area of foreign policy. We will ensure that it is central to our broader
foreign policy goals including eliminating poverty, supporting women and fighting terrorism
and violent extremism.
There has been a welcome growth in the number of countries with democratic political
systems and a respect for human rights. However the continued existence of authoritarian
states in many regions of the world shows there is a real need to continue the fight against
human rights abuses. As the people of Burma and Zimbabwe have shown the desire for a
life lived at liberty extends to all people in all parts of the world.
We will ensure that the Labour government's work supports the brave campaigners, trade
unionists, workers and journalists around the world who have often experienced immense
suffering in their determination to highlight human rights abuses. The annual Human Rights
Report that Labour launched in 1998 is one way to do this and is proof of our moral
commitment in this area.
We must not be afraid of using the power of military intervention where minority rights will
otherwise be abused and will work to forge a stronger international consensus on when and
how to intervene. However, we will always strive for the widest possible international
support for any military intervention. We recognise that military victories never provide
solutions but can provide the space for economic and political solutions to be found.
We will also ensure that fighting terrorism is consistent with our long-standing commitment
to human rights by ensuring that we are never complicit in torture or rendition to torture.
Comment: Add, page 17, line 42, at end of line:
“We unreservedly condemn the use of extraordinary rendition flights by any country and will support an independent inquiry into the allegation that UK airports ... Reply?.
Organised transnational crime
Crime cuts across national borders making a cohesive international and European response
vital. Organised international crime and the trafficking of drugs and people threaten lives
and communities, and undermine good governance, stability and development around the
world. We will continue to strengthen our own approach, through the Serious Organised
Crime Agency, and will strengthen international institutions including Europol and Eurojust.
Labour will also continue campaigning against modern day slavery including forced labour,
people trafficking and child labour. We have signed the Council of Europe Convention on
Action Against Human Trafficking and will ratify it soon.
The Crime Justice Citizenship and Equalities document also covers aspects of organised
crime.
Controlling arms and nuclear proliferation
"Saferworld welcomes the efforts made by the UK Government so far in tightening
domestic legislation on arms exports and acknowledges its leadership in pushing for
an International Arms Trade Treaty." Saferworld
Agreeing an international treaty to prevent the irresponsible international trade in arms is
essential to international stability and reducing conflict. Britain has led the way in calls for
an International Arms Trade Treaty to deal with conventional arms exports and will continue
to press ahead on this issue. The government is also committed to securing an international
instrument to ban cluster munitions which have a devastating effect on civilians across the
world.
Comment: Add, page 18, line 22 at end:
“We will end the use of so-called ‘smart’ cluster munitions currently in use by British forces namely those used in M85 artillery and M73 rockets.”
Supporting Argument: ... Reply?.
We will continue to press for a European Union common position making the EU's Code of
Conduct on Arms Sales legally binding. This will ensure everyone else is abiding by rules that
we already enforce.
As well as controlling conventional arms we recognise the serious threat that nuclear
proliferation represents for international security. We are committed to disarmament but
acknowledge that this can only be done safely on a multilateral basis through working with
the other recognised nuclear powers. The Labour Government has significantly reduced its
nuclear warheads to under half the levels planned in 1997, and will encourage other
countries to do the same. We will lead the way on nuclear weapons control and reduction,
working for a more robust implementation of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty in order
to ultimately free the world from nuclear weapons.
Comment: Delete from Page 18, line 29 “We are committed” to end of line 43 “the safety of its citizens” and Add:
“Article 6 of the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty demands that the present nuclear weapon ... Reply?.
Comment: As well as leading the way on nuclear weapons control ... 'we realise that this can be more effectively achieved by not purchasing the Trident delivery system' submitted by Weston CLP Reply?.
Labour recognises that the renewal of Britain's independent nuclear deterrent and the
decision to continue supporting US missile defence from related UK facilities have been
controversial. A wide-ranging debate was held within and outside the party on the renewal
of our nuclear deterrent, providing an opportunity for full debate before Parliament voted in
favour of renewal. Renewing the independent nuclear deterrent and continuing to allow the
US to use UK facilities as a relay station for satellite data are consistent with the
government's commitment to Britain's national security and the safety of its citizens.
Flexible, robust and balanced Armed Forces
We recognise the crucial role that our Armed Forces play in protecting Britain but also in
helping to promote peace and uphold human rights around the world. We do not at present
face a threat of traditional inter-state conflict but have to deal with new global security
challenges, from international terrorism to fragile states and regional tensions and conflicts
with global repercussions. It is therefore essential that we retain flexible, strong and
balanced Armed Forces, fully equipped to meet these challenges, including building our
expertise in post-conflict stabilisation and reconstruction. In order 5 to do this we will
continue to increase defence spending in real terms, by £7.7 billion by 2011.
Comment: It is not clear if the £7.7 billion increase mentioned is annual or over a number of years.
We should say something like "We do not at present face a threat of traditional inter-state conflict ... Reply?.
We take the protection of our Armed Forces very seriously. As a result of Labour's
investment our service personnel have never been better equipped. Over the last three
years we have delivered equipment valued at more than £18 billion to the Armed Forces.
Our reservists have already made important contributions in our operations abroad and
possess valuable skills which are in high demand in post-conflict situations. We will publish a
review to examine how we can best use these skills in our operations abroad and to ensure
15 that our reserve forces continue to play a vital role in the defence of the UK.
Supporting our Armed Forces and their families
Our Armed Forces are the best in the world and we should pay tribute to their dedication
and bravery. They are risking their lives for us daily and supporting them and their families
must be a priority. In the last two years we have introduced a new tax free bonus, funded
out of the Reserve and paid equally to all those serving on operations overseas, worth
almost £400 a month; a council tax discount for those on operations; and for all service
personnel, one of the highest pay rises in the public sector this year following on from last
years 9 per cent pay rise for the lowest paid private soldiers.
We continue to improve their accommodation, spending over £8 billion in the next 10 years.
We continue to invest in making sure their medical care, both at home and abroad, is world
leading, building on the creation of the military managed ward at Selly Oak hospital
Birmingham; and to improve their mental health care provision. Priority NHS treatment will
be extended to all veterans in the UK whose condition is considered to be attributable to
their service. We will publish a cross government Command Paper outlining further improved
measures for the welfare and support of our forces and their families.
Comment: If this is a policy document, it is rather weak simply saying we will publish another policy outline: "We will publish a cross government Command Paper outlining ..." Reply?.
Comment: after ... support of our forces and families.. 'by ensuring that their pensions are calculated by the yearly rate of inflation + 4%' submitted by Weston CLP Reply?.
Conflict prevention and resolution
The changed nature of warfare means that increasingly civilians are its victims, whether of
direct violence or of the displacement and disruption to their livelihoods. Preventing conflict
cannot be done by the UK alone and we will work with other international partners and
through strengthened international institutions to create a more peaceful world.
We will work across government to develop a comprehensive response to conflict
prevention and reconstruction and will build on the success of the Stabilisation Unit, jointly
owned by the Department for International Department, the Foreign Office and the Ministry
of Defence, in supporting countries emerging from violent conflict. In order to create global
stability we will offer £600 million towards conflict prevention, resolution and stabilisation
work around the world.
The UK has made important interventions in conflicts in many parts of the world from the
Balkans to Sierra Leone but we will work harder to prevent conflicts breaking out in the first
place through addressing its root causes, developing early warning mechanisms and
recognising the fundamental links between stability and development
We will continue to push for effective multilateral mechanisms for conflict prevention and
resolution through UN reform and through building the capacity of regional organisations.
We will also create a 1000 strong UK standby international civilian capacity - including
police, emergency services professionals and judges - to assist failing states and help in
conflict reconstruction and will press other nations to support this.
Managing migration
We live in an age of mobility, where globalisation has greatly increased the number of people
moving around the world. We will continue welcoming those who bring essential skills to the
UK economy and maintain our commitment to protecting those genuinely fleeing from
persecution. However, there are also new challenges posed by international population
movements and we will work to prevent illegal immigration through international, and
importantly, European cooperation. We will also work to ensure successful integration into
local communities.
Comment: We will also work to ensure successful integration into local communities.. 'and undertake to ensure that the false statements that appear regularly in the media are rebutted by an independent agency'. ... Reply?.
Migration can also be a tool for development. In many developing countries the money sent
by people working in the UK back to families and friends in other countries is the second
largest inflow into the economy, behind Foreign Direct Investment. However the benefits it
can bring need to be balanced with the potential challenges; migration is in some instances
blamed for the loss of highly skilled people such as doctors and nurses. We are committed to
eliminating the exploitation of all workers, including migrant workers, and we will work with
trade unions and other organisations to do so.
The Crime Justice Citizenship and Equalities document covers issues concerning the
domestic response to migration and cohesion.
Engaging in Europe
Comment: Cities of London and Westminster CLP add at the beginning of this section:
We reaffirm our commitment to keep Britain at the heart of Europe including the principle of joining the single currency, ... Reply?.
In Europe, Britain is a strong voice acting to secure the security and prosperity of its citizens.
Through our economic strength, international leadership on issues such as development,
trade and climate change, as well as support for EU enlargement, we continue to exercise
strong influence within the European Union. Our dedicated engagement in the EU means
that we can ensure that British citizens continue to get the best deal from our EU
membership whilst tackling global issues to ensure a fairer world for all.
We recognise that often the message we send on Europe is not positive or strong enough.
Being part of the European Union is vital for British jobs and trade and brings many other
benefits allowing British people to live, work study and retire in other European countries.
Our membership of the European Union has also meant strengthened working rights,
cleaner beaches, cheaper travel and communication costs for British people. In the run-up to
the 2009 European elections we will make clear positive arguments for our membership of
the EU by communicating these numerous and tangible benefits to the British people.
After the Lisbon Treaty
We have seen a renewed focus on Europe with the discussions surrounding the Lisbon
Treaty. The Treaty will introduce a series of sensible institutional changes to help make the
EU of 27 member states work more effectively and ensure tackling global poverty and
climate change are at the heart of the EU's agenda. With the ratification process having
cleared the Commons and now progressing through the Lords it is time to shift Europe's
focus beyond institutional change to the issues that really matter to people and their lives.
We will ensure that the EU works effectively by ensuring greater transparency in the
budgetary process and by rebalancing spending to meet the challenges of a modern global
economy. We will argue for the next European budget to give greater priority to new
challenges, particularly sustainable energy and adaptation. We will also continue to press
30 for more radical reform of the Common Agriculture Policy to ensure a better deal for
developing countries.
The Creating Sustainable Communities document covers the Common Agricultural Policy
Economic reform
"Usdaw agrees that our interests as a nation lie in being an active member of the
European Union, helping define its priorities and enhance the economic opportunities
that it provides." Usdaw
The European Union is vital for the success of business in the UK and any isolation of Britain
in Europe would have dire consequences for our economic strength. Our relationship with
the rest of Europe accounts for nearly 60 per cent of our trade and 3.5 million jobs depend
upon it. Our membership of the EU has meant low prices for British consumers in many areas
from phone calls to travel and the Single Market already provides British business with
access to a market of nearly 500 million people.
We will continue to work to deliver an effective single market - in particular in energy,
telecoms and services - to provide greater benefits to European consumers.
The agreement of the Lisbon agenda in 2000 was a historic step to achieving the most
competitive and dynamic knowledge-based economy in the world, founded on sustainable
economic growth and greater cohesion. As we approach the second cycle of the Lisbon
agenda we will ensure that it continues to meet the needs of EU citizens by promoting free
trade, increasing jobs, developing skills and investing in knowledge, innovation, research and
development.
The single market is also a social structure and depends on an active and responsible labour
market where people are given the skills they need to compete in the global economy. We
have already improved workers rights through EU legislation and our commitment to the
Social Chapter. Labour in government should recognise concerns about employment security
and workers rights whilst at the same time ensuring the EU retains a flexible and
competitive labour market. We support EU action, where appropriate, to improve fairness in
the workplace, and to maintain our commitment to the Social Chapter.
The Prosperity and Work policy document covers employment issues.
Environmental Union
Climate change knows no borders and can only be tackled through concerted international
action. Britain and the EU lead the world on climate change. The EU emissions trading
scheme is already the biggest environment policy in the world and at the 2008 Spring
Council the EU agreed a further package of measures to tackle climate change and ensure
energy security for its citizens including a 20 per cent emissions cut in greenhouse gases by
2020. We will build on this success by developing low carbon technologies across the EU,
extending the EU emission trading scheme to other sectors of our economy and introducing
initiatives to encourage greener consumer consumption such as the proposed cut in VAT on
environmentally-friendly domestic goods. The move towards a single energy market which
the Lisbon Treaty will facilitate is also an important step forward in ensuring that our
energy needs are met.
Enlargement
One of the key strengths of the EU has been its enlargement to 27 states welcoming in a
new era of stability and prosperity across the EU. We will ensure that the EU retains its
power to stimulate effective democratic reform. As the countries of the Western Balkans
have shown the prospect of EU membership encourages newly democratic regimes to
bolster the rule of law and to ensure greater transparency and accountability. We need to
keep the door open to our Eastern neighbours and others further afield and continue to
deepen our ties with them.
Britain has enjoyed great prestige as a champion of EU enlargement and we will continue to
support the enlargement of the EU to include Croatia and Turkey, and other accession
states where suitable, as long as the appropriate standards, significantly human rights
obligations, are met. The UK is also in favour of a reunited Cyprus and we should work with
both parties to promote a swift unification allowing full EU integration.
Tackling global challenges
"Terrorism, drug trafficking, climate change and migration are all transnational
concerns that can only be confronted by working in close association with the UK's
European partners."
Chichester CLP, Selsey branch
For a long time the EU was focused on securing peace and democracy within its own
borders however the challenges we face now are different. Europe needs to look outwards
to the threats beyond its borders that threaten security and prosperity within its borders
from climate change and religious extremism to nuclear proliferation. The EU must ensure
that its external policies contribute to greater fairness, democracy and development around
the world. In an increasingly interdependent world many of the major challenges we face
can only be solved by working with and through the European Union.
The European Security and Defence Policy (ESDP) has worked well in the missions in which it
has so far operated, notably a recent deployment in Kosovo. The situation in Kosovo has
also demonstrated the strength of the EU in ensuring stability through its commitment to
aiding Kosovo's economic and political development. However we recognise the limited
resources and capabilities of the ESDP and will encourage all member states to give greater
support. Whilst NATO will remain the cornerstone of our defence policy, and foreign policy
must remain a matter for national government, the development of the ESDP and its
partnership with other regional forces such as the African Union will contribute to more
effective conflict resolution and peacekeeping.
We believe Europe's voice in the world will be strengthened by developing the EU's Common
Foreign and Security Policy. This means that when EU member states unanimously agree on
a foreign policy issue we can speak and act together, with the authority of 27 countries
(and the world's biggest single market) behind us. To help, there will be an EU External
Action Service - bringing together existing resources from European institutions and
coordinating diplomats from the UK and other EU countries. We'll make sure that the UK is
strongly represented in this organisation whilst maintaining our independent foreign policy -
where we do not agree with our European partners, the UK can still pursue its own foreign
policy. We will work with our European partners, safe in the knowledge that there is no
threat to the UK's seat on the UN Security Council.
The European Union should and can be a model power in the world, building on its leading
position on international development, climate change and economic reform to help spread
peace and democracy world-wide. Britain outside Europe would be poorer, less influential
and less secure which is why we will continue to be at its heart.
Other links |
We believe Labour's role in modern society is to work through government, civic society and local communities for a more equal distribution of income, power, ... Reply?.